Miguel_Ortego
eCommerce & Consummers Law

Redes sociales y supresión de datos cautelarmente y con alcance mundial.

El Tribunal de Justicia de la Unión Europea («TJUE») avala que un juez nacional acuerde una medida cautelar que implique la supresión y/o bloqueo de «datos similares» a otros ilícitos y de los que el prestador de servicios de alojamiento («PSA») no tiene conocimiento efectivo; con un alcance mundial. Así se desprende de la STJUE (Sala Tercera), de 3 de octubre de 2019, en el asunto Eva Glawischnig-Piesczek c. Facebook Ireland Limited (C-18/18) en el marco de la Directiva 2000/31/CE («Directiva de Comercio Electrónico»-«DCE»-) actualmente en proceso de revisión.

El litigio se suscitó entre la Sra. Eva Glawischnig-Piesczek (diputada nacional austríaca) con motivo de una publicación en la red social Facebook por parte de un usuario en la que se incluía una foto de la diputada junto con un comentario contrario al honor (según declaró el tribunal de instancia). Ante ello, la Sra. Glawischnig-Piesczek remitió una carta a la red social para que retirara el comentario. Al no acceder a ello, interpuso contra Facebook una demanda ante el Tribunal de lo Mercantil de Viena que emitió un auto por el que cesara en tal conducta. Facebook se avino a ello sin perjuicio de la correspondiente apelación en donde el Tribunal Superior Regional de Viena confirmó el auto dictado en instancia si bien solo para el concreto comentario (contenido ilícito puesto en conocimiento de Facebook) y no los «datos similares».

Recurrida en casación por ambas partes, el Tribunal Supremo decidió plantear una cuestión prejudicial ante el TJUE para conocer, en esencia, si el art. 15 de la DCE impide que una orden de cesación de comunicación de contenidos ilícitos abarca también las declaraciones literalmente idénticas o de contenido similar («datos similares») aunque el PSA no tenga específicamente conocimiento efectivo de la ilicitud de éstas (art. 14 DCE). Y ello porque supondría imponer al prestado una obligación general de supervisión de datos transmitidos y/o almacenados (o de realización de búsquedas activas de hechos o circunstancias susceptibles de ser ilícitos), contrario al art. 15 de la Directiva. De apreciar que ello cabe en Derecho de la Unión Europea («UE»), el tribunal remitente también se pregunta cuál es el alcance de tal medida (en particular si llega a escala mundial).

Pues bien, el TJUE concluye que la DCE no se opone a que una medida cautelar como la que nos ocupa produzca efectos a escala mundial (en el marco del Derecho internacional que corresponda). Ello se deriva de una lectura del art. 18.1 junto con los considerandos 29 y 30 de la DCE (§49-50). De la misma manera, entiende que tal medida no implica una imposición al PSA de supervisar de manera general datos que almacena, ni una obligación de realizar búsquedas activas de hechos o circunstancias presuntamente ilícitas (§47).

Y, en fin, que tal medida cautelar se extiende a los «datos similares» al contenido ilícito efectivamente comunicado al PSA (entendiendo por estos aquel mensaje «cuyo contenido permanece esencialmente inalterado-§39-) «siempre que la supervisión y la búsqueda de los datos a los que se refiere tal medida cautelar se limiten a aquellos datos que transmitan un mensaje cuyo contenido permanezca esencialmente inalterado con respecto al que dio lugar a la declaración de ilicitud y que contenga los elementos especificados en la medida cautelar acordada, y en la medida en que las diferencias en la formulación de dicho contenido similar al que caracteriza a una información declarada ilícita con anterioridad no puedan obligar al prestador de servicios de alojamiento de datos a realizar una apreciación autónoma de ese contenido» (§53.II).

Fuente: Souslamaindelautre

18 Comments

  • W

    Wade Liu

    (Please kindly forward this to your CEO, because this is urgent. If you believe this has been sent to you in error, please ignore it. Thanks)

    Dear CEO,

    This email is from China domain name registration center, which mainly deal with the domain name registration in China. On 20-04-2023, we received an application from Hongqing Ltd requested «miguelortego» as their internet keyword and China (CN) domain names (miguelortego.cn, miguelortego.com.cn, miguelortego.net.cn, miguelortego.org.cn). But after checking it, we find this name conflict with your company name or trademark. In order to deal with this matter better, it’s necessary to send this message to your company and confirm whether this company is your distributor or business partner in China?

    Best Regards
    Wade Liu | Service & Operations Manager
    China Registry (Head Office)
    Tel: +86-2161918696
    Fax: +86-2161918697
    Mob: +86-13816428671
    6012, Xingdi Building, No. 1698 Yishan Road, Shanghai 201103, China

  • M

    Megan Atkinson

    Hi there,

    We run an Instagram growth service, which increases your number of followers both safely and practically.

    – Guaranteed: We guarantee to gain you 400-1200+ followers per month.
    – Real, human followers: People follow you because they are interested in your business or niche.
    – Safe: All actions are made manually. We do not use any bots.

    The price is just $60 (USD) per month, and we can start immediately.

    If you are interested, and would like to see some of our previous work, let me know and we can discuss further.

    Kind Regards,
    Megan

  • L

    Libby Evans

    Hi there,

    We run an Instagram growth service, which increases your number of followers both safely and practically.

    – We guarantee to gain you 400-1000+ followers per month.
    – People follow you because they are interested in you, increasing likes, comments and interaction.
    – All actions are made manually by our team. We do not use any ‘bots’.

    The price is just $60 (USD) per month, and we can start immediately.

    If you’d like to see some of our previous work, let me know, and we can discuss it further.

    Kind Regards,
    Libby

  • c

    click here to investigate

    Unquestionably imagine that that you said. Your favorite reason appeared to be on the net the easiest factor to consider of.
    I say to you, I definitely get irked whilst people think about concerns
    that they just don’t understand about. You managed to hit the nail upon the highest and
    defined out the entire thing without having side effect , folks can take a signal.
    Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  • M

    Megan Atkinson

    Hi there,

    We run an Instagram growth service, which increases your number of followers both safely and practically.

    – We guarantee to gain you 400-1000+ followers per month.
    – People follow you because they are interested in you, increasing likes, comments and interaction.
    – All actions are made manually by our team. We do not use any ‘bots’.

    The price is just $60 (USD) per month, and we can start immediately.

    If you’d like to see some of our previous work, let me know, and we can discuss it further.

    Kind Regards,
    Megan

  • B

    Brianna Brownbill

    Hi there,

    We would like to introduce to you Robin AI, the world’s first app that replaces your entire team with an AI assistant. This powerful tool generates human-like content, creates stunning designs, drives unlimited traffic, and more.

    Say goodbye to costly subscriptions and hello to an all-in-one solution. With a 30-day money-back guarantee, Robin AI empowers you to start your own AI-powered business and achieve unparalleled efficiency.

    Don’t miss this opportunity to revolutionize your workflow and boost your success.

    Discover the game-changing capabilities of Robin AI today: https://shorturl.at/anovz

    Brianna

  • L

    Leanna Valles

    Hi,

    I’ve just been on to miguelortego.com and thought this would suit you down to the ground.

    How would you like an AI assistant that can help you create high-quality videos, turn blogs into videos, and powered with a human-like voice-over?

    You can find out more here… https://shorturl.at/mnsOY

    Regards,
    Leanna

  • M

    Megan Atkinson

    Hi there,

    We run an Instagram growth service, which increases your number of followers safely and practically.

    We aim to gain you 400-1200+ real human followers per month, with all actions safe as they are made manually (no bots).

    The price is just $60 (USD) per month, and we can start immediately.

    Let me know if you wish to see some of our previous work.

    Kind Regards,
    Megan

  • w

    wat is aboutlove

    Greetings! I know this is kind of off topic but I was
    wondering which blog platform are you using for this site?
    I’m getting tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking
    at options for another platform. I would be fantastic if
    you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  • M

    Megan Atkinson

    Hi there,

    We run an Instagram growth service, which increases your number of followers both safely and practically.

    – Guaranteed: We guarantee to gain you 400-1200+ followers per month.
    – Real, human followers: People follow you because they are interested in your business or niche.
    – Safe: All actions are made manually. We do not use any bots.

    The price is just $60 (USD) per month, and we can start immediately.

    If you are interested, and would like to see some of our previous work, let me know and we can discuss further.

    Kind Regards,
    Megan

  • h

    how to pay for adult videos with paypal

    It is perfect time to make a few plans for
    the longer term and it’s time to be happy. I’ve learn this submit and if I
    may I wish to recommend you few attention-grabbing things or
    advice. Perhaps you could write subsequent articles referring to this article.
    I desire to read even more issues approximately it!

Deja una respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *